Monday, July 13, 2009

Tia Gerstner FINALLY Faces Consequences


Judge imposes 10PM curfew & eliminates driving 3.5 months AFTER fatal DWI accident kills classmate

“Prior to this incident, we have a young woman who was drinking underage, smoking marijuana. Those are all things that are obviously she should not have been doing that day and I just want to make sure that she continues on the straight and narrow while she's before the court.” ~~ ADA Perry Duckles

STORY

SCATS ~~ Personally, I'm outraged and disgusted by the fact it appears that this teen was permitted to: finish school; attend graduation; attend all the parties; and live her uninterrupted life. WHY IS THE DA FOOT-DRAGGING FOR THIS KID?

22 comments:

Anonymous said...

Perhaps Mr. Mueller's family wanted it this way. I know alot of times the DA would consult with the family of the deceased.

Anonymous said...

How nice 2:41. That tells us the DA isn't the one running our legal system doesn't it? God help us all.

Anonymous said...

2:41 That poor victim is not the only one that her irresponsible actions could have hurt. How about another unsuspecting car. It does not matter what that other family wants for clemency for this drunk drugged driver. She will kill someone else if she continues driving. She surely will not stop drugging. she was doing the same as that police officer that hit the pregnant woman except she was too hurt to run away.

Anonymous said...

Shame on you all! Don't you realize that a primadonna like Tia gets special treatment? Don't expect any jail time. They don't want her to break a nail.

Anonymous said...

She looks pretty happy here. Not too contrite or sorry. Suffering....probably not.
http://www.facebook.com/people/Tia-Gerstner/882755706

Anonymous said...

None of you know her story. She needs help before she is punished. She has lost two siblings. Her brother died three years ago from a speeding car on his bike ( driver was not intoxicated ) Joe Mueller was her best friend. The Mueller family would not press further charges because they know how sorry she is. She is enduring plenty of pain. The girl also weighs about 110 pounds as it is, and she blew a 0.11 that night. That is about two beers on her behalf. Joe is watching over her right now and the people who knew him know that.

SCATS said...

To 2:49AM ~~ I have no sympathy at all for ANY PERSON who drinks, then gets behind the wheel of a vehicle. Tia Gerstner is NOT the victim here.

I've suffered great losses and face many challenges in my life too. Adding my best friend to the destruction is not the path I choose to follow. It's too bad for the Mueller family that she did.

Anonymous said...

All of you are heartless. You don't know how it feels to lose your bestfriend forever and then have to live with the guilt. Tia loved Joey and would have never done anything to hurt him intentionally. For whoever tried to put up a facebook link of Tia u should take another look at her facebook. Her display is a picture that she and Joey took before all of this happened and she talks about how much she misses him. People make mistakes and she is paying for hers for the rest of her life, she doesn't need strangers telling her how bad of a decision she made because she already knows that. Tia is a sweet girl who is always nice to everyone and I just hope she can get through such a tough time in her life.

SCATS said...

To 1/16/2010 12:18 PM ~~ Oh puh-leeze!! Do you honestly believe Ms. Gerstner was unaware of the consequences of drinking and driving BEFORE she did it? IF SHE WAS AWARE OF IT, and I'm pretty certain anyone who has completed driver's education as a teen these days IS AWARE, then she DECIDED TO TAKE THE RISK. The only thing Tia learned was that the dice don't always roll her way.

Drinking and then driving is "intentional."

REAL FRIENDS DON'T DRIVE THEIR FRIENDS AFTER DRINKING!

Anonymous said...

It's crazy how everyone has such a strong opinion against Tia when they don't even know her OR Joey personally. Tia is serving his sentence and I don't think she'll ever do anything that stupid again. I know for a fact that she is plagued with guilt. Leave the whole thing alone, it's over.

SCATS said...

To 7:57PM ~~ It's not over unless no else does what she did. You dodged answering the question. People who do that on here do it because they know their position is indefensible.

Anonymous said...

Is this thing out of jail yet? So if someone where to kill her, AND, feel really really bad about it, they only have to go to jail for 6 months, right? I bet she'll be partying the day she gets out (if she's not already out...)

Anonymous said...

I hear she's been seen out partying and has been seen driving as well...

W
T
F

Anonymous said...

"no else does what she did"

Uh, respectfully - what the hell does that mean?

Drinking and posting is also intentional.

SCATS said...

To 3:16PM ~~ It means unless no one else drinks then drives. Simple.

Interesting that I get a post today when she DID IT AGAIN!! Feel free to eat your words & apologize, 2/04/2010 7:57 PM ;)

Anonymous said...

@2/4/10 7:57

"Don't think she'll ever do anything that stupid again?!?!? " Guess what, stupid is as STUPID TIA! cause she did it again!!!

Back To Jail!!!

Anonymous said...

I love the comments by the idiot that guaranteed that Tia would never do something like this again. Stop speaking on behalf other people's kids... especially when you don't live in their home and know what true brats they truly are.

If this girl was ANYTHING other than white, decent looking and having the Aquinas community behind her... she'd be rotting in prison right now. She didn't even finish out her sentence and didn't learn a damn thing.

WHEN she kills someone again, the blood will be on her parents' hands because of the spoiled brat they raised her to be and molded her into.

I hope she goes to prison so that she doesn't have to destroy the lives of another family.

SCATS said...

WARNING

BLOG Administration is not fond of name-calling & is exhibiting unusual patience with the comments here.

If you don't want your comment deleted or edited, do NOT call someone names (that includes "stupid" ... "idiot" ... "brat" etc.

Anonymous said...

Tia, did wrong, she needs to be punished,but what punishment. She needs help, she needs to be prayed for and a rehab center. Jail won't help she will come more angry than before. With Joey's accident he and his mom were at a Mother & son dance before the accident. It got out at 11 Pm, I was there. Mrs Mueller, let Joey go at that time witha 17 year old. He had been drinking during the party. She knew he had a habit of drinking and drugs. What Mom lets her kids out at that time.All partie4s were wrong.Joey was as drunk as tia & Billy. He had all the drugs in his back pack, that never OUT. Tia screwed up again, but she never got the help she needs. I am not sticking up for her she was wrong. But lets have some compassion.

SCATS said...

To 6:32PM ~~ Tia got "compassion" the first time with nothing but a slap on the wrist after she MURDERED her "best friend." I'm sorry but NO ONE EVER FINISHES DRIVER'S EDUCATION CLASS WITHOUT LEARNING IT IS ILLEGAL TO DRINK & DRIVE UNDER THE INFLUENCE. NO ONE.

It's time for Tia to pay.

SCATS said...

By the way, when you say " All partie4s were wrong" you forgot to note that it is possible for some to be more wrong than others. Tia gets that distinction. The others chose NOT to drive.

Anonymous said...

So why doesn’t anything more ever come from these incidents? Even from her first SWI and now her second. Who supplied the alcohol? What about the friends SUV? Either she had permission to use it or not. Seems to me loaning your vehicle to someone without a license (and who is drunk!) should be illegal. Why don’t they dig deeper in cases like this? Accountability on ALL actions.